Five Points Pizza

Reviews

• Billy H.

  star star star star star 8 June 2026

  I literally stumbled upon this place late night and went in for a slice. It was slammed pack, but they were able to take my order quickly, and the slice was out in no time.
  
  I would have to say that it's the best NY style pizza that I've had anywhere this year. The crust, sauce, and toppings were perfect. If you're around East Nashville, I highly recommend.

• Heather H.

  star star star star_border star_border 6 June 2026

  I'll start off by saying that I am the great great granddaughter of a wonderful pizza parlor owner in Aptos California. So I've had a crap load of pizza and I try it nearly everywhere I go.
  Recently relocated to Nashville and I asked around to see where the best pizza near downtown would be and I was told three different locations with this being one of them.
  I loved the exterior and the initial entrance. Myself and a coworker sat at the bar and we each had the slice and salad. For starters the salads here are awesome! His Greek salad looked great and I had the spinach, cranberry and Gorgonzola salad. It was very fresh and tasted great!
  The slice we both had was the meat of the day pie and it happened to be meatball with red onions. It was good. Very fresh. I am big on the dough though and the flavor as well as the sauce. So, here we go-
  They do not put sauce on their pizza it's like plopped on in spots. If you're a sauce person like myself you will want to order a side of sauce which does cost extra. They're sauce is very full of garlic which I love! Now their crust does leave something to be desired. It was flavorless and really really hard on the edge. I didn't even eat it and I'm a bread freak.
  Service was good and the place was packed when we left.
  Sadly, it did not rank in my top 5 or even 10 pizza parlors.

• Kat S.

  star star star star star_border 1 June 2026

  Want a whole pie okay or how about just a slice? The pizza slice was a good size.
  Got the veggie of the day which was roasted garlic, and my friend got classic cheese.
  Ordered half order of the garlic knots since it was a popular item.
  Gotta be honest I wasn't thrilled at all. They are presented nicely.
  But flavor-wise just not digging it. Way to doughy like enough to give you an upset stomach.
  The atmosphere is chill, typical pizza joint. Clean and quick service. Prices are reasonable.

• Ray R.

  star star star star star 28 May 2026

  Was out and about with the family and wanted to get some pizza. My wife looked on yelp to see what was close and Five Points Pizza came up. So we decided this was our spot.
  There were people lined up outside and told it was about a 30 min wait. But it ended up more like 10 min.
  The pizza is awesome, best I had in a while. It's thin and the ingredients are fresh. We had half T-Rex and half Zeus. Both were amazing and full of good flavor. Wash it down with a local Yazoo and Friday has begun.
  The service was fast and with a smile. This is now my #1 pizza place

• Brian F.

  star star star star star_border 13 May 2026

  The place I planned on going to for dinner was closed and my backup was also closed, so I ended up scrambling to find some place on Yelp and saw high ratings for this place. I was starving so I came here as a pre-dinner meal.
  
  I ordered the prosciutto and basil ($5) which was unique and I really liked it! The prosciutto added a nice saltiness and the basil was nice and fresh. I've surprisingly never had prosciutto on pizza but I might have found my new favorite pizza topping!
  
  It is a large slice of pizza too! It takes two paper plates to hold it up so you definitely get your money's worth. It really does remind me of the pizza that I had in NY with the thin crust.